All change please – the Williams-Shapps plan for the railway

the Williams-Shapps plan for the railway
Date Published

14/09/2021

Reading time

4 mins read

Author

Phil Evans

It’s been a few months since the long awaited Williams-Shapps Plan for Rail was published, with some early signs of reform already being introduced, such as the recent launch of new flexible tickets for commuters.

Whilst the report has generally been welcomed by the industry there is some concern - particularly from the unions - that the reforms don’t go far enough or that the Department of Transport (DfT) “now faces an extremely challenging and uncertain environment in which to implement its proposed reforms” (The House of Commons Public Accounts Committee in its “Overview of the English Rail System” report published on 7th July 2021). Whatever the view, it’s agreed by all that change is needed to ensure that we have a network fit for the future.

The proposed reforms herald the biggest change in UK railways in over 25 years and aim to bring the fragmentation of the system to an end with the creation of a new public body, Great British Railways, which will own the infrastructure, receive the fare revenue, and run and plan the network – spelling an end to the model of rail franchising which even the DfT called “flawed”.

The new model, which will build upon the approach taken by TfL Overground services, Merseyrail and many railways across Europe, including in Germany and Sweden, will use a concession model to contract with private partners to operate the trains. Great British Railways will specify the timetables, branding, most fares and other aspects of the service, and agree a fee with the competitively-procured passenger service operator to provide the service to this specification.

National Rail Contracts will succeed the emergency agreements currently in place and will act as a bridge to the new Passenger Service Contracts which will come into force in two years time and will include incentives to drive revenue growth.

Whilst the Williams review is at pains to highlight the progress and improvement made to Britain’s railways under privatisation, the green credentials of rail and its safety record, it paints a picture of complexity which it believes will not support the future needs of the country because no leader or organisation at local, regional or national levels has responsibility and accountability for making the whole system work. 

Indeed, the Williams review found that the railways are not getting the basics right; trains not running on time, the challenge of buying the right ticket at the right price and a railway that wasn’t accessible and inclusive for all those who want to travel. As a result, passengers often complained that trains were late, overcrowded and that journeys were stressful.

The review states that “urgent and radical change is needed to help the railway become more customer focused and financially sustainable, working in the national interest as a public service”. The hope is that a simpler structure and clearer leadership will make decision-making easier and more transparent, enabling the railways to be more efficient with the value generated being shared with the customers of the railways and the taxpayers.

 

 

The Williams-Shapps Plan for Rail represents the biggest change to the railways in 25 years, ending the fragmentation of the past and bringing the network under single national leadership.

The shared vision for changing Great Britain’s railways is summarised in a number of outcomes.

Working as one

  • New way of working with the private sector
  • Economic recovery and financially sustainable railways
  • New offer for freight
  • Simpler industry structure

Creating better outcomes for customers and local communities

  • Modern passenger experience
  • Retail revolution
  • Greater control for local people and places
  • Cleaner, greener railways

Innovating and developing

  • Increased speed of delivery and efficient enhancements
  • Skilled, innovative workforce
Download the infographic

 

The sector’s disparate structures, each with silos and individual priorities, do not always work together to meet the needs of passengers, freight customers or taxpayers. It is clear that digital and technology enabled business transformation will also be required in support of the establishment of Great British Railways and the ‘whole system approach’ to running our railways - whether it’s easier and more flexible methods of payment, or the integration of the railway with other transport services (for example users to be able to plan, book and pay for multiple types of mobility services through one digital channel).

However, ahead of the creation of Great British Railways in 2023, new flexible season tickets have already gone on sale to accommodate the new flexibility and work-life balance employees have enjoyed whilst working remotely due to the pandemic.

The paperless tickets will allow travel on any 8 days in a 28-day period, with passengers able to tap smartcards or scan mobiles at the station with no need to select the days of travel in advance. The independent watchdog for transport users, Transport Focus, has commented that “This is a positive step towards much-needed longer-term reform of how rail tickets are sold.”

Working in partnership with our customers, we’re well placed to support the railway sector with the aspirations set out in the Review through the use of data & insight, behavioural science, digital applications, automation and machine learning. True digital transformation requires that we deliver sustained change to people, processes and technology through smart thinking, digitally-enabled solutions and service excellence. In subsequent blogs, we will be exploring in more depth other key themes and points raised in this landmark report.

Find out how we’re helping the railway sector

Written by

Dr Phil Evans

Dr Phil Evans

Director for Transport, Capita Public Service

As a domain expert, Phil provides business development, sales and strategy expertise to the energy and transport sectors specialising in new technologies, innovation and digital transformation. His key focus is on decarbonisation, particularly in relation to smart grids, energy storage, smart cities and the link to transportation electrification strategies, as well as emerging mobility services such as mobility-as-a-service.

More of our thinking

Read more

Thinking about your organisation?

Get in touch